Logo
  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter



This website is authored by Lester Levy, Esq.
a founding member of JAMS.

  • About
    • About Lester Levy
  • The Basics of Environmental Mediation
    • What types of Environmental Cases can be mediated?
    • The Benefits of Environmental Mediation
    • The Environmental Mediation Process
    • Insurance Company Involvement
    • The Mediation Outcome
  • Case Studies
    • Case Study 1: Objectivity as Resolution Tool Provided Through A Neutral Expert
    • Case Study 2: Working Together
    • Case Study 3: Swift, Fair and Efficient: Awarding Compensation to Toxic Tort Victims
    • Case Study 4: Sequenced Regulatory and Insurance Negotiations
    • Case Study 5: How Communication Both Causes and Ends Conflict
  • Blog
  • In the News
  • Contact
You are here: Home / The Basics of Environmental Mediation / The Benefits of Environmental Mediation

The Benefits of Environmental Mediation

the benefits of environmental mediationThe issues which underlie environmental disputes are better resolved though mediation than through trial because “trial procedures” are not designed to address the substantive and procedural complexities these cases present. Science is very useful in helping to:

  • assess liability (who is responsible for causing the contamination) and
  • allocate responsibility (how to apportion the costs of investigation and cleanup among multiple parties)

Environmental science (including hydrogeology, chemistry, engineering) is key to determining where the contamination is located, what kind of contamination it is, how much of it is located there, if it is moving and what are the best (most efficient and cost effective) methods for cleaning it up

Mediation provides a private forum where the key issues can be thoroughly examined and professionally debated by the disputants themselves, their colleagues and experts without having to conform to formal rules of evidence, and can be resolved through voluntary and informed agreements specifically tailored to each case and not limited by pre-determined “court remedies”

In most cases, mediation is cheaper (certainly, the dollars are spent more directly on resolving the important issues at hand), it creates a more effective and rational result, it does not escalate disagreements into more destructive conflict – and may serve to build trust among the participants

Environmental mediation allows – indeed encourages – the participation of insurance carriers in helpful ways that are not available in court. Insurance coverage is often needed – if not critical — to help fund necessary levels of investigation and cleanup, because parties want to access the insurance dollars that are available to them under polices currently in effect or which they had purchased in the past

Also, because potentially responsible parties and businesses may be insolvent or no longer in existence (e.g., historical owners, operators or generators)(read: gas station or dry cleaner contamination cases often involve parties who are deceased or have no assets other than the insurance policies they bought when they were in business)

Risk management and control: these disputes involve high risks and high transactional costs (read: there often is a lot of money at stake and these cases are very expensive to try in court)

Cleanup efforts can take many years to complete so it is a best practice to negotiate a comprehensive agreement, based on realistic future projections of the time and money required (e.g., costs and efficacies of remedial alternatives) (read: most environmental settlements involve work to be done, money to be paid and other required actions into the future – these are better handled through negotiation rather than judicial fiat)

 

  • The Basics of Environmental Mediation
  • What types of Environmental Cases can be mediated?
  • The Benefits of Environmental Mediation
  • The Environmental Mediation Process
  • Insurance Company Involvement
  • The Mediation Outcome
Tweets by @environmentadr

Environmental Mediation Newsletter

Sign up to receive my environmental mediation newsletter on a monthly basis

My Latest Posts

  • The inter-generational theft of Brexit and climate change
  • Our Drinking Water Regulation Is So Weak Even Flint’s Water Got A Pass
  • Environmental Mediation: A New Paradigm for Resolving Multi-Party Disputes
  • Flexibility Is Key to Success in Mediation
  • Leaving the EU would put our environment at risk

About Me

lester-levy

I strongly believe in the value of mediation – said another way, environmental mediation really works. I would go even further: I believe that environmental disputes are perfectly suited to the mediation process – perhaps more so than any other area of legal practice. I have formed these views after mediating environmental cases for more than 20 years, throughout the United States, and having worked with thousands of lawyers, companies, insurance carriers, regulatory agencies and courts. My … Read more

My Latest Posts

  • The inter-generational theft of Brexit and climate change
  • Our Drinking Water Regulation Is So Weak Even Flint’s Water Got A Pass
  • Environmental Mediation: A New Paradigm for Resolving Multi-Party Disputes
  • Flexibility Is Key to Success in Mediation
  • Leaving the EU would put our environment at risk

Connect with Me

Lester Levy

JAMS- New York
620 Eighth Ave. (NY Times Building)
34th Floor
New York, NY 10018
P (212) 751-2700

JAMS- San Francisco
2 Embarcadero Center
Suite 1500
San Francisco, CA 94111
P (415) 982-5267

Copyright 2016-2020 Lester Levy | Site developed by Good2bSocial