Logo
  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter



This website is authored by Lester Levy, Esq.
a founding member of JAMS.

  • About
    • About Lester Levy
  • The Basics of Environmental Mediation
    • What types of Environmental Cases can be mediated?
    • The Benefits of Environmental Mediation
    • The Environmental Mediation Process
    • Insurance Company Involvement
    • The Mediation Outcome
  • Case Studies
    • Case Study 1: Objectivity as Resolution Tool Provided Through A Neutral Expert
    • Case Study 2: Working Together
    • Case Study 3: Swift, Fair and Efficient: Awarding Compensation to Toxic Tort Victims
    • Case Study 4: Sequenced Regulatory and Insurance Negotiations
    • Case Study 5: How Communication Both Causes and Ends Conflict
  • Blog
  • In the News
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Case Studies / Case Study 2: Working Together

Case Study 2: Working Together

environmental mediation - case study 2As my father would say, “this one was a sparkler.” Basically, this was a run-of-the-mill dispute among 6 parties over the costs of cleaning up PCE contamination in the groundwater. Each party was either a landowner or dry cleaning operator on three neighboring properties. The environmental regulatory agency had identified the parties as potentially responsible for a groundwater plume that presented a potential threat to local drinking water wells. Participants in the mediation were lawyers, clients, insurance carriers and environmental consultants for each party.

Early in the lawsuit, the parties agreed to ask the judge to put the discovery on hold in order to avoid unnecessary litigation time and expense and, instead, to work together in mediation to develop a joint remediation plan to present to the regulating agency. The parties’ were united in the following goals: (1) to share their independent, on-site investigation results; (2) to jointly share the costs of investigating the off-site “regional” groundwater contamination plume; (3) to agree on the most effective and least costly remedial approach; and then (4) to prepare a joint remedial action plan agency approval. After the agency approved their joint approach, the parties met in mediation and agreed on an equitable allocation of past and future costs and settled the lawsuit.

What did this “alternate” dispute resolution achieve?

An informed settlement based on the true costs of cleanup, a fair division of those costs among the parties, avoided unnecessary litigation procedures, discovery, motion practice and trial costs, avoided duplicative environmental investigation costs, presented a unified and collaborative face to the regulators and to the court which ultimately led to the acceptance of a remediation plan that was consistent with the interests of all parties.

I say further that there was a benefit to all in the reduction of partisanship and the stresses which litigation brings – and in the fostering of a professionally collegial environment where valuable services were delivered to all clients.

  • Case Study 1: Objectivity as Resolution Tool Provided Through A Neutral Expert
  • Case Study 2: Working Together
  • Case Study 3: Swift, Fair and Efficient: Awarding Compensation to Toxic Tort Victims
  • Case Study 4: Sequenced Regulatory and Insurance Negotiations
  • Case Study 5: How Communication Both Causes and Ends Conflict
Tweets by @environmentadr

Environmental Mediation Newsletter

Sign up to receive my environmental mediation newsletter on a monthly basis

About Me

lester-levy

I strongly believe in the value of mediation – said another way, environmental mediation really works. I would go even further: I believe that environmental disputes are perfectly suited to the mediation process – perhaps more so than any other area of legal practice. I have formed these views after mediating environmental cases for more than 20 years, throughout the United States, and having worked with thousands of lawyers, companies, insurance carriers, regulatory agencies and courts. My … Read more

My Latest Posts

  • The inter-generational theft of Brexit and climate change
  • Our Drinking Water Regulation Is So Weak Even Flint’s Water Got A Pass
  • Environmental Mediation: A New Paradigm for Resolving Multi-Party Disputes
  • Flexibility Is Key to Success in Mediation
  • Leaving the EU would put our environment at risk

Connect with Me

Lester Levy

JAMS- New York
620 Eighth Ave. (NY Times Building)
34th Floor
New York, NY 10018
P (212) 751-2700

JAMS- San Francisco
2 Embarcadero Center
Suite 1500
San Francisco, CA 94111
P (415) 982-5267

Copyright 2016-2020 Lester Levy | Site developed by Good2bSocial